I have a mother-in-law who I absolutely love and appreciate. However, we got off on the wrong foot in the beginning. Harper and Olsen state: "Mothers-in-law usually discover early that their daughters-in-law are not like them, and in some cases this may be upsetting." This seems to have been the case when I met my husband's mother. He was the baby of the family and the last weddings had taken place five years before ours so any differences between the other sons wives had long been worked out and I felt like a bit of an outsider. They all loved gardening and canning and sewing and quilting, just like my mother-in-law. I had very limited experience with any of those things and didn't particularly enjoy those activities.
It also didn't help that for years my husband's mom had harbored a wish for him to marry the daughter of family friends and on more than one occasion she slipped up and called me by the name of the girl she wished I was! On top of that, I had just been raised differently and my upbringing played a part in my mother-in-law's disapproval right from the start. I remember as we were doing some wedding planning one day she asked where I was going to display my trousseau at the reception. I just looked at her blankly and in my head thought, What century is this? Do people still do that? She was completely aghast when I told her that I didn't have one.
On another occasion, shortly after we were first married, we had gone to my in-laws for Sunday dinner. My sister was with me at the time and later overheard my mother-in-law laughing with one of my sisters-in-law about an incident earlier when she had asked me to slice up a loaf of homemade bread for the dinner. I had sliced up the entire loaf as I thought she had asked me to do and as I would have done in my own large family of ten siblings, but she thought it was so funny that I would have cut the whole loaf instead of just the the slices we'd need for dinner. It was such a little incident but I was actually really hurt to know that not only was I some kind of laughingstock to her, but that she was sharing her observations to others in the family too.
Added to all of this was the fact that my husband and his mother had a very close relationship before our marriage and it took some major adjusting after the wedding for both of them to realize that things needed to be different. Before the marriage it was totally fine for them to talk on the phone regularly or for my husband to confide in his mom about everything; after marriage it began to create some tension. For example, one day my husband was trying a new recipe and had a question about one part of the directions. I was sitting right there working on some homework when he picked up the phone to call his mom to ask for help and as he asked the question I looked at him and mouthed, "Why didn't you ask me? I could have told you that!" So in my head I'm thinking, Great! Now my mother-in-law thinks I'm hopeless in the kitchen too! And sure enough, a couple of days later, she showed up with groceries and recipes for me to try (with helpful notes written in the margins).
Harper and Olson say: "The husband needs to realize that strengthening his marriage and making certain that his wife feels secure with him is the biggest single thing he can do to help his wife and his mother develop a quality relationship." In those early days, I was definitely feeling insecure and a bit resentful of the relationship that my husband had with his mom. I felt like an intruder. But one day after my husband had gone immediately to the phone to share some good news with his mom, I told him we needed to talk and I explained how I was feeling and that I thought if this continued that his mom would see me as an interference in their closeness, that not only would she and I never develop a good relationship but that my husband and I wouldn't be as close as we should be either. When I presented my side of things and how this appeared to me, my husband finally could see how this wasn't healthy for our marriage. He began making changes but it was difficult because my mother-in-law was hurt by what she felt was her son pulling away from her. I knew I needed to do something to help her to know that he wasn't going anywhere and that I still wanted him to be part of her life even while we made changes that would strengthen our married relationship and help us create our own family separate from our parents.
Harper and Olson state: "Research shows that when daughters-in-law disclose information about themselves, communicate openly, accept differences, use empathy, and push for a relational connections, they can have high-quality relationships with mothers-in-law." We started by not only continuing to accept invitations of my in-laws but we made a point of inviting my husband's parents to do things with us occasionally like see a movie together or have dinner. In this way we let them know that we welcomed their company in our lives too. I engaged my mother-in-law in conversation, shared things about myself, and even asked her for advice. But I think the biggest thing came when I was perusing the books on her bookshelves one day and asked if I could borrow one. My mother-in-law is an avid reader and so am I. Her daughters and daughters-in-law have never been much for reading so this one thing we have in common has become a huge bond for us. We have traded many books over the years and had lots of discussions about our favorite authors. This one small thing has brought us so much closer together.
I think she realizes now that while I'm not necessarily the girl she would have picked for her son, I'm the girl her son picked; that I've been exactly what he needed and wanted and, because he has been happy, that's made her happy too.
Harper, J. M. & Olsen, S. F. (2005). "Creating Healthy Ties with In-laws and Extended Families." In C. H. Hart, L.D. Newell, E. Walton, & D.C. Dollahite (Eds.), Helping and healing our families: Principles and practices inspired by "The Family: A Proclamation to the World" (pp. 327-334). Salt Lake City, UT: Deseret Book Company.













